Friday, April 1, 2016

Budget as a Policy Tool for Economic Growth: Insights from the Top MBA College in Greater Noida

The top MBA College in Greater Noida, Ishan Institute of Management & Technology has been a front runner in performing intellectual surgeries on important policy tools. The Union Budget has been presented amidst positive feedback from the corporate sector and has generated generally cautiously optimistic investor sentiment. From today and onwards the world’s largest democracy gets ready to initiate yet another financial year. While there are expectations and wish lists that are unique to different stakeholders of the Indian economy, it makes enormous good sense to ask if the budget can be used as a policy tool by the Government of India to enhance economic growth rates. To put it across in crystal clear terms, we may ask if the budget can be used to achieve double digit economic growth rates.

While it is fashionable to think on the lines of the Washington Consensus that asserts trickle- down economics and the role of the government as a gateway for managing the economy with respect to dynamics of the free markets rather than act as a gatekeeper with a centrally commanded economic planning structure, one must warn against the ill effects of over-emphasising financialization. The term “financialization” is essentially borrowed out of the book of corporate captains, academicians and alumni of the Harvard business school and has been extensively used in corporate budgeting and financial planning to shed flab and get corporate enterprises into a mean and lean structure by doing away with fiscal profligacy. Yes, it makes sense to cut down on public expenditure that is unmindful and we in India for sure do not want to witness a Troy or Odyssey on the lines of the Greek tragedies. Yet we must accept that economic growth shall not perpetuate on its own by streamlining costs. The turnaround of the economy in the long run depends on the handling of structural, cyclical and institutional factors that the state must address unlike corporate enterprises. To this extent at Ishan, the top MBA college in Greater Noida we believe that the concept of the welfare state mandates attention.

First one of the biggest cyclical issues that remain a worry is the ailing agriculture sector. Subsidies on fertilizers must be dealt with a necessary streamlining of costs. The area that needs consolidation is water resources management and the redesign of the existing system of irrigation that leaves our agriculture and farmers to the mercy of the rain Gods. The creation of a fund alone will not solve the issue. Recall that MGNREGA was a great innovation based on pump priming by the previous government but climaxed leading to non-creation of physical assets and demand pull inflation owing to higher income levels. It shall be great to design a water resource management system and bringing the same under the reign of MGNREGA on a condition that the work in progress on such projects for rain water harvesting, building of dams, water channels, canals, wells and tube wells shall be disclosed publicly as per Right to Information and that consecutive rounds of funding shall be anchored to successful achievement of asset creation in the previous rounds. This is easier said than done but should be done to improve the agriculture sector while improving fiscal discipline and transparency in reporting of projects.

Secondly the structural issue that needs to be solved is the one of start up firms and their capacity to create jobs. The days of centralized economic planning based on the Feldman model of erstwhile USSR are gone. Start –up firms may be leverage by the government to create jobs and improve income levels. For this to happen the government may opt for a pay-roll based income tax cut for start-up firms that invest a threshold level of financial resources in skill development programs like web designing, mobile app development, coding, payment gateway development, digital marketing, big data and internet of things. This will have the twin effects of raising start-up investments on training and development of human resources while addressing the need to move towards an investment based economy away from the consumption based economy that we now have. More over start-up firms in the manufacturing sector may be given pay roll subsidies under the Make in India campaign to stimulate employment generation in the rural areas.

As regards institutional factors, there is a pressing need to realize that in the long run we are all dead and staying in the growth curve shall require technological progress. Corporate income tax rebates may be announced for R&D programs. Moreover with world class business and technology school brands in IIMs and IITs, angel investors willing to finance the creation of product based and technology based start-up firms out of R&D programs at IIMs and IITs may be considered for tax holiday for three years without any interest or penalty obligations.


At Ishan Institute of Management & Technology, the Greater Noida, the first MBA College in Greater Noida, academicians of the Management Department pray for sustainable economic growth of India and intellectually support the pro-GDP growth policies of the current government.